Tēnā koutou katoa.
Thank you to everyone who has contributed to the Commission’s investigation so far. Southlanders have generously shared their experiences, concerns and aspirations with us through meetings, surveys and discussions across the region. Councils, iwi, key stakeholders, representative bodies and community organisations have provided information and perspectives that have helped shape our thinking.
After considering a range of possible changes, we identified two options for detailed investigation: a single Southland council; and two councils, one for Invercargill and one for wider Southland and Gore. We looked closely at both options, drawing on all evidence gathered through the investigation, including feedback from communities and stakeholders across Southland and independent financial modelling.
Our decision is to put forward a single Southland Council for further consultation.
Some of the decisions involved in arriving at a single Southland Council have not been easy.
One of the clearest messages we heard was how strongly Southlanders value their local identity, local voice and the ability to influence decisions affecting their communities. We also heard genuine concerns, particularly from rural, remote and geographically dispersed communities, that a single Southland Council might feel more distant. We heard concerns that decision-making could become too centred on Invercargill, or that Invercargill would overshadow smaller Southland communities, including those in rural areas. We understand these concerns and have taken them seriously.
At the same time, we heard strong concerns about affordability, rising costs and getting good value from local government. We also heard a desire for local government to operate as efficiently as possible, with less duplication and less need for residents to navigate between councils.
As part of comparing the two options, we asked consultants MartinJenkins to undertake independent financial modelling of each. Both options would involve significant costs to put in place, but the modelling found a substantial difference in their longer-term financial results. Under the modelling, a single Southland Council would recover its transition and financing costs and provide a net financial benefit of $66 million over 25 years. The two-council option would not recover those costs within 25 years and would have a net cost of $4.7 million.
We considered the financial modelling alongside everything else we heard, including the importance Southlanders place on local identity, local representation and decisions being made close to their communities. Overall, we concluded that a single Southland Council was the stronger option for Southland’s future, but only if communities continue to have genuine control over important local decisions.
That is why local boards are fundamental to a single Southland Council. Local boards would be elected by local communities, make decisions about specified local matters and have dedicated funding for local priorities. Unlike community boards, which can be established or disestablished by councils and depend on councils for the decision-making powers they have, the existence and core decision-making role of local boards would not simply depend on the decisions of a future Southland Council. This would give communities greater certainty that important local decisions would be made locally. We consider local boards the strongest way to protect local decision-making under a single Southland Council.
We have also proposed how communities would be represented under a single Southland Council, including where wards and local board boundaries should be. The proposed boundaries are based on the information we have gathered throughout the investigation and our understanding of the communities and connections across Southland. We know that no set of boundaries or representation arrangements will perfectly reflect every community or connection. This is a draft plan, and consultation is an important opportunity to test and improve it.
We genuinely want to hear what Southlanders think. If there are things we have got wrong, connections we have not adequately reflected, or ways the proposal could better protect local representation while achieving the benefits of a Southland-wide council, please tell us. If there are parts of the draft plan that you particularly like, please also tell us.
Your feedback will help us decide whether to issue a final reorganisation plan and, if so, how the proposal should be refined to best serve Southland’s communities into the future.
Nō reira, tēnā anō koutou katoa.
The Local Government Commission
Dr Sue Bidrose (Chair)
Bonita Bigham
Andrew Turner.