Reorganisation of local government in Southland – a new Southland Council

Closes 5 Feb 2027

Why has the Commission decided on a single Southland Council?

There are 2 questions that can be answered within this section.

You can read this section and the questions either:

Read about why the Commission has decided on a single Southland Council - HTML format

Why has the Commission decided on a single Southland Council?

Why is change needed?

The Commission’s investigation identified several challenges and opportunities facing local government in Southland.

Current arrangements were often described as fragmented, with responsibilities spread across four councils. The Commission heard concerns about duplicated work and different approaches between councils, rising costs, infrastructure pressures, environmental management, whether councils could attract and retain the specialist skills they needed, and how well councils could respond to future challenges. The Commission also heard that Southland could benefit from councils working more closely together, with clearer responsibility for decisions, and better coordinated planning and services.

The Commission concluded there was sufficient evidence that alternative local government arrangements could better address a number of these issues and opportunities than the current council structures.

Stronger regional coordination and clearer accountability

Many of the issues affecting Southland extend beyond individual council boundaries. Environmental management, river catchments, flood protection, biosecurity, emergency management, transport networks and economic development all require coordinated decision-making at a regional scale.

The Commission concluded that a single Southland Council would provide the clearest framework for addressing these issues by creating a single council responsible for both Southland-wide matters and the services currently managed by city and district councils. This would provide clearer accountability and reduce the need for coordination between multiple organisations.

A stronger organisation for the future 

The Commission heard consistent feedback about the importance of councils’ ability to attract and retain the specialist skills they need.

Southland’s councils face growing demands for infrastructure renewal, environmental management and regulatory requirements, while some specialist skills can be difficult to recruit for. The Commission concluded that a single Southland Council would be better placed to attract and retain specialist staff, reduce duplicated roles across councils and use resources more efficiently. A larger organisation would also provide greater flexibility to respond to changing community expectations and future challenges.

A stronger long-term financial position

Affordability and the rising costs of council services were major concerns raised during the investigation.

The Commission asked consultants MartinJenkins to independently model the financial effects of both options investigated in detail. MartinJenkins’ report showed that both options would involve significant costs to put into place. However, modelling found that a single Southland Council would save significantly more in ongoing operating costs because it would replace four councils with one, while the two-council option would retain two separate organisations. 

The modelling showed that a single Southland Council would recover its transition and financing costs and provide a net benefit of $66 million over 25 years. The two-council option would not recover the costs of moving to this structure within the same period and would have a net cost of $4.7 million.

These figures compare the modelled costs of each option with the costs of retaining the current four council arrangement. The modelling does not provide estimates of changes to individual rates bills. Future rates would depend on decisions made by the new council about funding, debt, services and how rates are shared across different properties and areas. 

The modelling also found that a single council would be better placed to manage financial pressures because its revenue, debt and ability to borrow would be managed together across Southland. However, reorganisation would not remove the underlying pressures facing councils, including rising infrastructure costs, a slow-growing rating base and increasing debt. 

The ability to respond to future changes and challenges

The Commission considered not only Southland’s current needs, but also how local government arrangements would need to respond to changes in the future.

Different parts of Southland are likely to face different population, economic and environmental pressures over time. The Commission considers that a single Southland Council would be better able to respond to these challenges and plan for Southland’s longer-term needs.

Protecting local voice and local identity

The strongest message heard throughout the investigation was the importance Southlanders place on local identity, local representation and having meaningful influence over decisions affecting their communities. 

The Commission also heard concerns that a single Southland Council could be perceived as more distant from local communities, and that larger population centres, particularly Invercargill, could have greater influence in a single council structure. Geographically dispersed, smaller townships and rural areas were particularly concerned about being overshadowed, or losing their local voice, within a single council structure. 

The Commission found that a two-council structure could provide a greater sense of protection for local voices and local identity. However, it considers these concerns can also be addressed within a single-council structure through carefully designed wards and local boards that keep important decisions close to the communities affected.

Local boards are a fundamental part of the Commission’s preferred option. They are intended to ensure that forming a single Southland Council would not mean all decisions being made centrally. Local boards would have their own elected members, decision-making responsibilities and dedicated funding for local matters. They would make decisions about matters affecting their communities, while Southland Council would be responsible for matters that need to be managed across Southland. The Commission considers this could protect local decision-making and provide a strong and consistent form of local representation across Southland.

Potential disadvantages

The Commission acknowledges that a single Southland Council has its own disadvantages and risks. These include:

  • Concerns that some communities may feel more distant, or less strongly represented, in relation to central council decision-making;
  • Concerns regarding the potential influence of larger population centres, particularly for smaller geographically dispersed and rural townships;
  • Significant transition costs associated with establishing a new council organisation;
  • Uncertainty for council staff during the transition process; and
  • The possibility that local identity could be weakened if local governance arrangements, including wards and local boards, are not appropriately designed and empowered accordingly.

The Commission considers that many of these risks can be reduced through careful design of representation arrangements, local boards, service delivery arrangements and transition planning. However, it acknowledges that these issues will remain important matters for community feedback during consultation.

Overall conclusion

After considering all evidence gathered during the investigation, the Commission concluded that both reorganisation options would improve on the current local government arrangements in Southland. 

However, when assessed against the requirements of the Local Government Act 2002, the Commission found that a single Southland Council was the stronger option overall. In particular, the Commission found that a single Southland Council would provide stronger regional coordination, clearer accountability, greater organisational capability, improved long-term financial sustainability, and a more durable framework for responding to Southland’s future opportunities and challenges. 

At the same time, the Commission considers that meaningful local decision-making and local identity can be maintained within a single council structure through strong local board arrangements.

For these reasons, the Commission’s preferred option is the establishment of a single Southland Council to replace Environment Southland, Gore District Council, Invercargill City Council and Southland District Council.

1. Do you agree that a single Southland Council would provide:
2. Are there any other advantages or disadvantages of a single Southland Council that you think we should consider?